Top 3 Best Training Collars for Dogs – Review

Best Training Collars for Dogs

Dog training can be performed in a number of ways, with as many methods available as there are breeds of dog.  Indeed, dogs display a variety of personality types, ranging from timid to confident to stubborn, and each training style is not one-size-fits-all.  For some dogs, an electronic collar which provides static shock at the press of a button is the best way to reliably and safely train an animal, especially from a distance.

There are many benefits to electronic collar training.  A common reason to use this method is for off-leash training, where the dog’s attention must be able to be reliably and effectively attained, no matter the distraction.  Other instances include dangerous behaviors, such as food aggression or dog aggression.  The “punishment” that is delivered when the dog misbehaves is often enough of a redirection that the animal quickly associates the improper behavior with receiving a shock.  For most dogs, simply wearing the collar is enough of a reminder to behave appropriately.

A non-behavioral reason to use an electronic collar for training is to teach aversion to certain animals or objects.  For instance, when training a dog to avoid rattlesnakes, an electronic collar is often used.  Whenever the dog approaches a caged rattlesnake, a high intensity shock is administered which quickly teaches the dog to avoid this dangerous animal.  In many ways, shock collars are essential tools for keeping animals safe.

What should you look for when purchasing an electronic collar?  Important considerations include varying levels of shock intensity (owners should use the lowest possible setting that provides a response from the dog), non-shock modes (such as vibration or beeping), rain and water resistance, durability, and a long working range.  Listed below are reviews on the three best electronic training collars for dogs.

Best Long-Range Electronic Training Collar
One of the greatest advantages of using an electronic collar is being able to control your dog from a distance, which is perfect when teaching property boundaries or prey drive aversion.  The Fiddo Electric Dog Collar has a 330 yard range, which is perfect for training within the house, yard, or at the park.  One of the best features of this product is that it is 100% rain resistant, allowing it to be used during inclement weather, ideal for dogs that have high energy requirements and need to go outside and play regardless of the conditions.

As far as usability, this collar provides a wide range of functionality.  The collar administers vibration, electric shock, beeping, and a flashing light for customizable use.  In addition, 100 shock levels are available, which means a setting can be found that is perfect for each pet.  As always, it is recommended that users test the shock values on themselves before administering any aversive techniques to their pets.

From an electronic standpoint, this system is sophisticated in that the receiver and remote will not interfere with other electronics – an especially useful advantage when using the collar indoors!  The collar and receiver sync as quickly as ten seconds, eliminating wasted time during a training session.  In addition, the nylon collar is durable and dries quickly, which is perfect for those rainy day sessions.

One downside of this collar is that it uses rechargeable batteries that can take up to 6 hours to fully recharge.  In addition, users may not find the lighted capability to be useful in comparison to the vibration, shock, and beeping functionalities since the light is not readily visible by the dog.  Users should also be wary when using the collar on a low setting, as the vibration levels are on a continuous adjustable loop.  For instance, if the collar is set to “0,” accidentally pressing the down button, instead of the up button, can set the shock to “100,” instead of “1.”

Despite limited drawbacks, this collar is overall an incredible value for the price of $34.99.  The collar’s durability, rain resistance, and long range make this unit an indispensible training device for dogs that require shock or vibration training.  Backed by a 90 day warranty, consumers should also be confident in their purchase.

Best Electronic Training Collar for Multiple-Pet Households
For dog owners who are trying to train more than one pet at a time, having one remote that can control two collars is a necessity.  This is only one selling point of the ever-popular Petrainer PET998DBB device.  Like the Fiddo collar, this Petrainer system can be used when the dogs are up to 330 yards away, allowing optimal opportunity to train your dogs for off-leash control.   Unlike Fiddo, the dog collar receiver is 100% waterproof (whereas Fiddo’s product is water resistant), allowing more peace of mind during training sessions in wet conditions.  For dogs who enjoy going for a swim or rolling in the snow, this collar is indispensible.  The remote is also easy to use and has a backlit screen ensuring use in low-light conditions is made easy.

For ultimate individualization and customization, this unit has four functions for corrective training:  vibration, shock, beep, and light.  The vibration and shock settings have 100 levels that deliver accurate stimulation each time, ensuring consistency in training.  The system has a power saving feature which conserves power to extend the battery life of a single charge.

For users who are new to electronic dog collar training, this Petrainer device is highly recommended, as it was developed with the novice user in mind.  One of the best features of this system that enhances its usability for beginners is auto protect mode, which prevents dogs from being over stimulated by shock or vibration.

There are few drawbacks associated with this device.  However, one is that there is no button lock to prevent accidental shocking of an animal.  For instance, some systems allow the buttons to be disengaged when the remote is not in immediate use, in case the remote is placed a pocket or out of reach.  Since the shock delivered is continuous until the button is pushed a second time, this feature can cause unnecessary correction, leading to confusion.

Despite this drawback, this system is one of the highest rated electronic collars on the market.  With its dual use capability, it is among the most useful of devices, as well.  For the purchase price of $58.99, consumers receive a transmitter, two receivers, two collars, two charging cables, one charger, a test bulb, and 3 metal probes.  With a one year limited warranty, consumers are guaranteed to get their money’s worth.


Best Short Range Electronic Training Collar
For the dog owner who is looking for a collar that is perfect for short range use, such as inside the house or in a small yard, the Petrainer PET998DRB model is highly recommended.  Although this collar is rated for use up to 330 yards, it is most reliable for distances up to 300 yards.

Like its sibling unit, the PET998DBB described above, this unit is suitable for all small, medium, and large dogs that weigh more than 15 lbs.  Also like the other two models already described, this electronic dog collar has four modes of functionality, with 100 levels of vibration, 100 levels of static shock, a single tone beep, and a light mode.  Unlike the PET998DBB, this unit is water resistant (not water proof), meaning it can be reliably used in the rain but should not be submerged in water.

This unit is also useful for dog owners that are new to the realm of electronic collar training, as it also has an auto protect mode that prevents a dog from accidentally being over stimulated.  In addition, the remote and collar come with a rechargeable lithium battery with power save options to promote a long battery life.  The remote has an ergonomic handle for comfortable use during extended training sessions, as well as a light mode that improves visibility in low-light settings.  The remote and receiver quickly and easily sync with one another, making the set up process easy and straight forward.

Downsides to this product are that the unit is not fully water proof, which limits its capability in extremely wet conditions.  Additionally, some users have claimed that the lowest shock setting of “1” is much higher than the lowest shock setting on other models, which may make it unsuitable for small dogs.  However, the vibration mode also has 100 settings, giving this product great range.

For the price of $32.99, which includes a remote, a transmitter, a collar, a charger, and 3 metal prongs, this product is certainly one of the most affordable electronic collars on the market.  With a 365 day limited warranty, Petrainer insures that the product received is high quality.

Ultimately, when choosing to use an electronic collar for your dog training needs, you should use a safe, reliable, and accurate system that has intuitive handling and reliability.  Although some pet owners find the use of electronic collars inhumane, it is important to remember that any training method, when used inappropriately, can have negative implications.

Best Long-Range Electronic Training Collar Best Electronic Training Collar for Multiple-Pet Households Best Short Range Electronic Training Collar

Featured image credit : John Garghan

Top 3 Best Training Collars for Dogs – Review vào lúc: October 2nd, 2016 bởi Lan Hoang
The following two tabs change content below.
A blogger with a great enthusiasm for dogs, I am delighted to know and write a story about dog's health, care and tips. Besides that, I also love camping, listening to psychedelic rock (Arctic Monkeys rule!) and Reddit.